Listen on Apple Podcasts Listen on Spotify Listen on SoundOn
If Only You Had Listened
Isaiah 48:17–19; Matthew 11:16–19
If only you had listened to my commandments! That is the Lord’s lament in Isaiah (48:18). But his people did not listen. Instead of prosperity and security, they experienced the loss of everything they held dear: relatives, homes, and the Temple. It was the fateful year of 586 BC.
We encounter a similar refusal to listen in the Gospel.
John identifies Jesus as the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world. Jesus declares that among those born of women, no one greater than John has arisen.
Yet others look at these two men and reach very different conclusions.
John’s austere way of life earns him the accusation that he is possessed. Jesus eats and drinks with others and is dismissed as a glutton and a drunkard.
What is going on here?
Jesus answers with a scene from the marketplace. Children invite their companions to play at weddings and funerals. They play the flute, but nobody dances. They sing a dirge, but nobody mourns. Whatever they propose, the others refuse to join in.
John’s preaching sounds like a funeral lament: repent, judgment is approaching. Jesus’ meals with tax collectors and sinners sound like wedding music: God is welcoming people home.
One fasts. The other feasts.
Both meet with rejection.
John is too severe. Jesus is too free with his welcome. There is always something wrong with the messenger.
But what would happen if the people listened to God? Isaiah describes peace flowing like a river and righteousness like the waves of the sea.
And what would happen if, instead of rejecting John and Jesus, they listened to them? John’s preaching would require repentance. Joining Jesus at the table would mean sitting beside people they preferred to avoid.
Criticising the messengers allows them to remain where they are.
“If only you had listened.”
Two thousand years later, we can still find reasons to keep our distance. A preacher is too demanding—or does not demand enough. The Church is too strict—or welcomes the wrong people. Of course, messengers can fail, and criticism can be justified. But criticism can also become a way of ensuring that no message ever reaches us.
Jesus ends by saying that wisdom is vindicated by her works. Beyond the accusations, there are lives being changed: sinners turning back to God, the sick being healed, the excluded finding a place at the table.
Isaiah sees the river of peace that might have flowed. Jesus hears the music to which people will not dance.
What are we hearing in John’s fasting and Jesus’ feasting?
An invitation—or another reason to complain?
Biblical Reflections on the Gospel of Mark
Year of Mark - Get it from Amazon
Scripture Attribution
New Revised Standard Version Bible: Catholic Edition,
copyright © 1989, 1993
the Division of Christian Education of the National Council
of the Churches of
Christ in the United States of America.
Used by permission. All rights reserved.
Content License
© 2025 Krakus.
Licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0
(Creative Commons Attribution–NonCommercial).